"The fishing experience with Patrick was great and Marcus the bartender on the lobby was fabulous."
Marianne from United States
read full review
"Site had everything beach, pool, bar, restaurant, bicycles kayaks, happy hour activities."
Andrew from United States
read full review
"Resort is amazing! Love the ambiance of the resort."
Angela from United States
read full review
"BEAUTIFUL, Friendly, Safe, great pool, delicious food and so much more!!!"
Melanie K from United States
read full review
Beachfront resort in Islamorada with free kayaks, paddleboards, and sister-resort access
Amenities & Pool
Amara Cay Resort offers complimentary access to kayaks, paddleboards, and bicycles for its guests. A free shuttle and Rum Runner boat taxi provides access to the amenities at sister resorts Three Waters and La Siesta. The property's zero-entry pool has in-pool loungers and overlooks the private beach area.
Rooms
Spacious rooms are decorated in a coastal chic style and include private balconies with Atlantic Ocean views. Each room comes with a flat-screen TV, a work desk, and a safety deposit box as standard. Guest room access is secured through a key card wristband system.
Location & Activities
The on-site full-service marina offers fishing charters, and a 'Fish Like a Local' dock activity is led by Patrick Frampton. The History of Diving Museum is 4.9 km from the hotel, and Anne's Beach is an 8-minute drive. Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park is located 8 minutes away by car.
Dining & Entertainment
On-site dining options include the Reelcatch restaurant and the Tiki Bar, which serves classic American cuisine and custom cocktails. A daily happy hour from 5 to 7 pm offers half-price drinks at the Tiki Bar. Evenings feature live local music events with performances by artists such as Mark Edward Hill.
Family & Services
Kids can join scheduled foam parties and paint-and-juice events organized on the beach. Pet bowls are available on the property, and facilities are accessible for disabled guests. The hotel provides luggage storage and transfer services within a 6 km radius.
Highlights
Location: Islamorada, 8 min from Anne's Beach and History of Diving Museum
Sister Resorts: Free shuttle and Rum Runner boat to Three Waters and La Siesta
Rooms: Spacious suites with coastal chic decor and private balconies
Dining: Reelcatch restaurant and Tiki Bar with daily happy hour
Activities: Zero-entry pool, free kayaks, paddleboards, bikes, and fishing charters
Family: Dedicated kids' foam parties and paint-and-juice events
Must-do experiences
Snorkel at John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park for vibrant marine life.
Visit the Vintage Marketplace for local arts and crafts treasures.
Enjoy fresh conch fritters at Morada Bay Beach Cafe's sunset view.
Explore the Florida Keys History Museum for rich local heritage.
Take a sunset cruise with Robbie's for unforgettable views and fun.
Select your room type
Amara Cay Resort provides a range of room types, including doubles, family rooms, and suites, along with breakfast, free cancellation, and special offers.
Quadruple Room Sea View
2 persons
380 sq. feet
2 King Size Beds
Balcony
room details
Oceanfront Queen Room
2 persons
380 sq. feet
2 King Size Beds
Balcony
room details
Suite Sea View
2 persons
650 sq. feet
2 King Size Beds
Balcony
room details
Show all rooms
Room Availability and Pricing Calendar
See today's rates and availability for your selected dates!
Facilities
Amara Cay Resort offers amenities for a comfortable stay and memorable Florida Keys experiences
Facilities: Very good
7.9/10Review score
General
Non-smoking rooms
Paid Wi-Fi
Parking
24-hour reception
Express check-in/ -out
Pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Wheelchair access
Security
Luggage storage
Private beach
Lift
Smoke detectors
Electric vehicle charging station
Key card access
Sports & Fitness
Fitness centre
Diving
Snorkelling
Cycling
Golf course
Fishing
Services
Free shuttle service
Pet amenities available
Room service
Housekeeping
Laundry
Shops/Commercial services
Welcome drink
Dining
Restaurant
Poolside snack bar
Snack bar
Special diet menus
Business
Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying
Children
Children's menu
Facilities for people with disabilities
Toilet for disabled
Spa & Leisure
Heated swimming pool
Outdoor swimming pool
Beach access
Sun loungers
Sun terrace
Garden area
Leisure/ TV room
Pool with view
Shallow end
Room features
Air conditioning
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Media
AM/FM alarm clock
Show more
Amara Cay Resort Location
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, 33036,
Map view
City landmarks
Landmark
Indian Key State Historic Site
1.1 mi
Landmark
Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park
1.1 mi
Monument
Hurricane Monument
1.7 mi
Museum
History of Diving Museum
3.0 mi
Landmark
Bamboo Charters
3200 ft
Landmark
Bay and Reef Company
3200 ft
Landmark
A Fishing Guide
3400 ft
Landmark
True Island Adventures
3500 ft
Gallery
Pasta Pantaleo Signature Gallery
1.5 mi
Gallery
Gallery Morada
1.5 mi
Landmark
FNX Club by Islamorada Fitness
4900 ft
Island
Upper Matecumbe Key
1.9 mi
Landmark
Key Dives
1.1 mi
Landmark
Easy Adventures Boat Tours
1.1 mi
Landmark
Reel Crackers Outfitters
1.1 mi
Landmark
Dee Cee Charters
1.1 mi
Landmark
Anne s Beach
1.7 mi
Gallery
Michelle Nicole Lowe Art Gallery
1.9 mi
Landmark
Beats Land Charters
1.4 mi
Nearby
Sea Monkeys Water Sports
400 ft
Seamonkey's Scuba Diving
400 ft
Bud n' Mary's Sportfishing Marina
1200 ft
Early Bird Fishing Charters
1200 ft
Cloud Nine Charters - Private Trips
1300 ft
Bud and Mary's Dive Center
1300 ft
Miss Islamorada Charter Fishing
1300 ft
Bud and Mary's Marina
1300 ft
Strictly Business Fishing Charters
1300 ft
Flipside Charters
1300 ft
Fearless Fishing Charters
1300 ft
Restaurants
Reelburger
600 ft
80001 Overseas Hwy
Galley Girls Cafe
1700 ft
79851 Overseas Hwy Mile marker 79.8
Kev's Cafe
1700 ft
79851 Overseas Hwy
Explore Islamorada
Activities & Attractions
Top Attractions
Activities
Dining
Entertainment
Indian Key State Historic Site
20-minute walk
Historic site with remnants of a former island community; accessible by kayak or boat tours.
Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park
20-minute walk
A unique botanical park featuring pristine hiking trails and lush flora; ideal for nature enthusiasts.
Hurricane Monument
30-minute walk
Memorial commemorating the 1935 hurricane; great for a scenic stroll and reflection.
History of Diving Museum
10-minute drive
Museum showcasing the evolution of diving equipment; excellent for diving history buffs.
Sea Monkeys Water Sports
2-minute walk
Water sports center offering jet ski rentals and banana boat rides; fun for thrill-seekers.
True Island Adventures
15-minute walk
Guided eco-tours showcasing local wildlife; perfect for relaxation amidst nature.
Bud n' Mary's Sportfishing Marina
5-minute walk
Offers deep-sea fishing charters; a must for fishing enthusiasts seeking adventure.
Reelburger
3-minute walk
Casual eatery known for hearty burgers and seafood sandwiches; family-friendly atmosphere.
Galley Girls Cafe
7-minute walk
Charming café serving fresh breakfast and café favorites; known for vegan-friendly options.
Kev's Cafe
7-minute walk
Cozy diner with iconic Key lime pie; perfect for hearty breakfasts in a laid-back setting.
FNX Club by Islamorada Fitness
20-minute walk
Local fitness studio offering classes and events; ideal for those looking to stay active.
Pasta Pantaleo Signature Gallery
10-minute drive
Art gallery featuring vibrant local artwork; hosts events and exhibits ideal for art lovers.
Local transportation
City Centre
Islamorada 6 min · 2.4 mi
Bus
Bus stop 13 min · 5.2 mi
Want to see Exclusive Early Booking Rates for the Florida Keys?
Get exclusive Florida Keys rates now!
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 16:00-23:59
Check-out
until 11 am
Internet
Wireless internet is available in the entire hotel at additional cost.
Breakfast
All visitors are offered a buffet breakfast for a fee.
Children & extra beds
There are no cots provided in a room. There are no extra beds provided in a room.
Pets
Pets are allowed on request.
Year renovated:
2012
Number of floors:
5
Number of rooms:
110
Former name
Hampton Inn & Suites Islamorada/The Islamorada Resort
Ratings & Reviews
Read what previous guests have shared about their experience at Amara Cay Resort.
Cleanliness
8.2/10
Comfort
8.3/10
Facilities
7.9/10
Free Wi-Fi
8.7/10
Location
8.7/10
Staff
8.2/10
Value for money
7.2/10
Pros
Ocean views
Comfortable rooms
Water sports access
Family-friendly environment
Quality food
Cons
Inconsistent housekeeping
High dining prices
Guest reviews
based on 2018 reviews
4/5
based on 538 reviews
7.9/10
No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.
Open reviews
Show more reviews
Questions of the users
About Amara Cay Resort
Is food and beverage service available on-site at the resort?
18 November 2023
Yes, breakfast is served from 8:00 AM to 10:30 AM, while lunch and dinner are offered from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM on weekdays and until 10:00 PM on weekends.
What is the policy regarding pets, specifically dogs, at the resort?
12 December 2023
The resort allows up to two dogs per reservation for a fee of $50 per night for each dog.
Is surf fishing allowed on the beach?
21 November 2023
Yes, surf fishing is permitted on the beach, with equipment provided through a program operated by Captain Kevin on Wednesdays and Fridays from 10:00 AM to noon.
Are there swimming facilities available at the resort's beach?
05 January 2024
Swimming is certainly allowed at the beach, and there are stairs leading into the water for easy access. Partial ocean view rooms are located on the north and south side of the building at the end of the hallway adjacent to the ocean.
Does the resort have rooms equipped with balconies?
15 October 2024
Yes, all guest rooms feature balconies for guests to enjoy.
Is an airport shuttle service offered at the resort?
30 October 2023
No, there is no airport shuttle service provided, but guests can use Keys Shuttle for transportation to and from the airport.
Are mini-refrigerators available in the guest rooms?
10 December 2023
Yes, every room is equipped with a mini-refrigerator for guest convenience.
Is there a bar and restaurant on-site?
29 November 2023
The resort features two bars and one restaurant with options for both indoor and outdoor dining as well as room service.
Can guests park on the property without a reservation?
17 January 2024
Yes, private parking is available on-site without the need for a reservation, although charges may apply.
What are the check-in and check-out times for guests?
22 February 2024
Check-in begins at 4:00 PM and check-out is required by 11:00 AM. Special requests for early or late check-in/out can be made, but they are not guaranteed.